top of page

Pricing a House in Columbia SC: Why 2021 Numbers Will Cost You

Courtney McCullough
11 minutes ago
5 min read
For Sale Sign In Yard of Columbia, SC Home

Pricing a house in Columbia SC starts with what buyers are paying this month, not what a neighbor got in 2021. Look at homes that closed in the last 90 days, close to yours in size and condition. Then look at what is sitting unsold. The right number is the one that gets showings in the first two weeks. If it does not, the price could be the problem.

Why Courtney knows this I talk to sellers about price almost every week. The hardest conversation is the one where a house is worth less than the number they have in their head. This is a very common thing. The neighbors said they sold their house for list price, when in fact that was just what it went under contract with and they offered seller closing costs and closed $10k less than the contracted price due to requested repairs and/or appraisal shortage. The neighbor already moved out and never told you the dirty details. Those are the details I get during my research on pricing properties.

Why does it feel like my house should sell for 2021 money?

Because back then it did. Houses went fast, multiple offers were normal, and a lot of people sold for well over asking.

Multiple offers are back in some price ranges. But it is not 2021. Buyers are asking for repairs. They are asking for closing cost help. They have time to say no.

If you bought in the last few years, especially new construction, the gap can be real. You may have paid top of the market. That stings. I get it. But the buyer in front of you only cares what the house is worth today.

Why does the Zestimate miss so often?

It is a computer guess. It doesn't know your kitchen was redone in 2019. It doesn't know your roof is 18 years old. It doesn't know the busy road behind your fence or the railroad track near to your home.

It also leans on old sales. In a market that moves, that means a lot of the data is behind. And Zillow has been found to have listings show pending that were not even active due to system glitches.

Use it as a starting point if you want. Do not use it as your price.

What do I actually look at to set the price?

Start with closed sales. Not active listings. Not pending. Closed. That is what buyers and lenders really paid.

Stick to the last 90 days if you can. Stay close to your house in size, age, and style. A Forest Acres ranch and a Lexington two story do not compare, even at the same square footage.

Then look at active listings near you. Those are your competition today. If three similar homes are sitting for 40 days, that tells you something too.

Here is the market data to anchor it. October stats for Lexington and Richland County in October was $358,729

What does the appraiser care about?

Most buyers use a loan. The lender sends an appraiser. The appraiser looks at closed sales, not your hopes.

If you price too high and get an offer anyway, the appraisal can come in low. Then you are renegotiating on day 20 instead of day 1. That is a bad spot. Pricing close to the comps keeps that from happening.

What is the real cost of pricing too high?

The first two weeks matter most. That is when the most buyers see a new listing. If your price is off, they scroll past.

Then the house sits. Buyers start to wonder what is wrong with it. You drop the price, but now you are the stale listing on the page. Sellers who start high often end up selling for less than they would have if they had started right.

You also pay while it sits. Mortgage, taxes, insurance, utilities, the lawn. Every month is real money.

Pricing to Sell: Your Checklist

Pull closed sales from the last 90 days, same area, same size, same style. Look at what is active and what has sat for more than 30 days. Be honest about condition. Old carpet and a dated kitchen cost you. Ask your agent for the price, the list, and the story behind it. Decide your floor before you list. Know the number you will say yes to. Plan a price check at day 14. If showings are slow, talk about it then. Stay away from any agent who tells you only the biggest number you want to hear.

Should I list high and come down later?

I would not. It is tempting. It feels safer. But buyers search by price range. If you list over their range, they never see you.

A fair price early gives you the most eyes. More eyes means more showings. More showings is how you get offers, and sometimes more than one.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find out what my house is worth in Columbia SC? Ask for a comparative market analysis from a local agent. It uses closed sales near you in the last 90 days. A computer estimate can help as a starting point, but it misses condition, updates, and your street.

Should I price my house slightly higher to leave room to negotiate? Usually not. Buyers shop by price range, and a high number can keep them from ever seeing your listing. A fair price at the start brings more showings and stronger offers.

How long should it take to sell a house in Lexington SC? It depends on price and condition. If you have had very few showings in the first two weeks, that is a sign to look at the price. Ask your agent for the current days on market in your area.

What happens if my house appraises for less than my price? The buyer and you will need to work it out. You can lower the price, split the difference, or the buyer can bring cash to cover the gap. Pricing near the comps up front helps avoid it.

Does a Zestimate matter when pricing a house in Columbia SC? It is a rough guess. It is not a valuation. Local sales and your home's real condition matter far more.

Final thoughts Price is the biggest lever you have. A great photo can help and a clean house can help. But a house priced right sells, and one priced wrong sits.

If you are thinking about selling in the Midlands, call or text me. I will pull the real numbers for your street and we will go over them together.

Courtney McCullough, Pawmetto Homes Team at Tzedi Co Realty. 803-307-7788.

bottom of page