top of page

Inspection Repair Request in Columbia SC: 6 Mistakes Sellers Make

Courtney McCullough
19 hours ago
4 min read
Home inspector checking a panel in a Columbia SC house

The buyer's inspection came back and now you have a repair request. Take a breath. Read the whole list, sort it into safety and water items versus cosmetic ones, and answer inside the deadline in your contract. You can fix an item, offer a credit, or say no. Most deals survive an inspection repair request in Columbia SC when the seller answers fast and stays calm.

Here is why I keep saying that.

Why do I keep seeing sellers stumble here?

I go through repair requests with sellers on a lot of contracts. The inspection is where a smooth deal gets tense, because the buyer just got a long list about a house you love. And they will never feel the same memories you created in that home. Remember, they are looking to make their own memories but must ensure the house has minimal issues.

The mistakes below are the ones I watch happen. Most are easy to skip.

Why does the first reaction matter so much?

Mistake 1 is answering while you are mad. It happens alot. You read page 4 and want to fire off a no.

Don't. The buyer's inspector is paid to find things. A 40 page report on a 25 year old house is normal. Read it, sleep on it, and call me before you reply.

Do I have to agree to everything on the list?

Mistake 2 is saying yes to all of it. You do not have to.

Sort every item into one of three piles.

Safety and structure. Water intrusion, active roof leaks, electrical hazards, a failing HVAC. These usually get fixed or credited.

Maintenance. A sticky door, a loose handrail, a dirty filter. Easy wins. Fix them cheap and move on.

Cosmetic or age related. Scuffed paint, an older water heater that still works. These are the items you can politely decline.

Mistake 3 is the opposite one. Saying no to everything. Buyers who feel brushed off start asking whether they want the house at all. Giving a little on the big items buys goodwill on the rest.

What if the report says something my disclosure did not?

Mistake 4 is forgetting your disclosure. In South Carolina the Residential Property Condition Disclosure Act says that if you find out your disclosure is materially inaccurate, or something happens that makes it inaccurate, you have to correct it promptly or make reasonable repairs before closing. That is SC Code 27-50-60. The same law also says the buyer still has the duty to inspect, so an inspection finding does not mean you did something wrong.

I'm not your attorney or your CPA. Run this by your closing attorney before you count on it.

If you knew about a problem and left it off the form, talk to your attorney before you respond to the request.

Should I fix it myself or give a credit?

Mistake 5 is fixing things the cheap way with no paperwork. A repair with no receipt is a repair the buyer will question.

For anything big, like plumbing, electrical, roof, or foundation, use a licensed pro and keep the invoice. Hand the buyer the receipt. That one page settles a lot of arguments.

A credit is cleaner when the work is large or when the buyer wants to pick their own contractor. Ask the lender first. Seller credits have limits that depend on the loan type, and an FHA or VA buyer can have extra repair rules from the appraisal.

Quick checklist before you answer: Read the full report, not just the summary. Get 2 quotes on the big items. Ask the lender how much credit the buyer's loan can take. Check your contract for the response deadline. Call your attorney if the report touches your disclosure. Put the answer in writing.

What if I miss the deadline on an inspection repair request in Columbia SC?

Mistake 6 is letting the clock run. Your contract sets a due diligence period, and the buyer's right to walk away or ask for changes is tied to it. The South Carolina state contract shows the due diligence as a date you key in. Our Central Carolina contracts have 10 business days.

If you wait until the last day to answer, you leave no room to negotiate. A fast answer, even a partial one, keeps the buyer feeling heard.

Here is how I like to handle it. Day one, read the report and mark each item. Day two, get quotes and call the lender. Day three, send a written response with what you will fix, what you will credit, and what you decline. That pace works on a Lexington house or a Forest Acres one.

Also, ask for the buyer's agreement in writing before any work starts. That way everybody is looking at the same page when the work is done and the final walk through comes around. Nobody is arguing over what was promised.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to make every repair a buyer asks for in South Carolina?

No. Unless your contract says otherwise, a repair request is a request. You can agree, counter with a credit, or decline. The buyer then decides whether to move forward under the contract.

Can a buyer back out after the inspection in Columbia SC?

It depends on your contract and the due diligence period. If the buyer is still inside that window, they can usually terminate. Once it passes, they have less room. Check your dates.

Is a credit better than doing the repair myself?

Sometimes. A credit is faster and cleaner on large jobs. Repairs are better when the item is small and cheap. Ask the lender about limits before you offer a credit.

What if the lender's appraiser finds repairs too?

That can happen, mostly with FHA and VA loans. The lender may require the repairs before closing. Talk to the buyer's lender early so nothing surprises you at the end.

Should I get a pre-listing inspection to avoid this?

It can help. You see the list before the buyer does and can fix things on your own timeline. It does not remove the buyer's own inspection, so plan for both.

My take

Repair requests feel personal, but they are a normal step. Answer fast, sort the list, and keep the paperwork. If you want a second set of eyes on the list before you reply, call or text me.

Courtney McCullough, Pawmetto Homes Team at Tzedi Co Realty. 803-307-7788.

bottom of page